(based on the article by Tathagata Bhattacharya-The Week. I captured what the author intended to communicate about this project, reproduced certain printed content to avoid ”distortion”)
One amongst a few things, I truly enjoy these days, in solitude, besides relishing the gradual movement of silence to pacify, detoxify the anguished body of mine, is reading thought-provoking articles on many a kind of issue, surprisingly BIG visions by SMALL people. The write-up by Tathagata Bhattacharya on “Little minds and Big visions” {The Week} has captivated me so much that I felt like highlighting it in my space. Tathagata starts his article with Paulo Freire’s quote in Pedagogy of Hope: Reliving Pedagogy of the Oppressed
….“The idea that hope alone will transform the world, and action undertaken in that kind of naiveté, is an excellent route to hopelessness, pessimism, and fatalism. But the attempt to do without hope, in the struggle to improve the world, as if that struggle could be reduced to calculated acts alone, or a purely scientific approach, is a frivolous illusion”.
Tathagata Bhattacharya-The Week mentioned that through their film, which was shot almost entirely on the roof of their home on a handheld digital camera, young boys Tapa Bhowmick and Rinku Babu Mondol, inmates of Muktaneer, a home for destitute boys run by {link:Centre for Communication and Development (CCD)} in Madhyamgram, reached out to the International audiences. Their film has been selected for the “Auburn International Film and Video Festival for Children and Young Adults” to be held in Sydney. The film has also been sent to participate in many other International Film Festivals held across such as the “Kids for Kids International Film Festival” in Naples, the “Chicago International Children’s Film Festival”, the “Tehran International Children’s Film Festival” and “Fike, New Zealand”.
…….The author of this article captured the essence of this film in Rinku’s words….”the children play kings of various countries, each king makes a unique declaration. One king says his country will not have any mosquitoes so that children do not fall prey to malaria and dengue. Another promises that children in his country will always play, while another king says every child will receive a certain amount of money so that he does not have to work. But, ultimately, they realize that reality is painfully different. It hurts their conscience and they take an oath to ensure that every child has access to education and health care, and that no child has to work in brick kilns or shrimp farms”.
Rinku, who is adept at Still and Video Photography, who has a natural instinct to capture life, aspires to become a doctor – both to serve poor people and to make money. ‘Í have seen what poverty is. My father passed away when I was very young. We went to stay with my mother’s parents, who, too, were poor. Had the centre not come to my rescue, God knows what would have happened. I have got so much from here. I have to pay back as well”
{link :One more excellently written post on such brilliant young children : Through the Eyes of Children}
I am both amazed by and proud of this simple yet profound statement from young boys, who, unfortunately can not attend their film screening in Sydney, as their home CCD is now facing severe financial crunch. As mentioned in the article, the home does not have funds for airfare for 40 children. And it also has not received any assistance from the Centre or the State, a few staff members stopped taking salaries, a few walk to work and back to save money.
I wonder, why can not the National carrier in the skies – The Air India take up the responsibility of carrying aross this brilliant crew to the Island of Kangaroo? Why can not a heritage hotel endorse their basic living facility so that they can represent the country through their honest, truly inspiring endeavor at a film festival of such International a stature? Why can not….if one thinks, one pauses amidst the hustle-bustle of one’s life, there would definitely be many an option. I am astounded by the fact that there are no endorsers from Indian Corporates, for these young Indian boys who are poised to represent India, one of the BRIC economies, a flourishing knowledge economy. Or is this due to inadequate a level of saliency about such accomplishments amongst Corporates ? Political leaders ? Media ? Child Welfare authorities? Bureaucrats ? Obscene amounts of money are wasted for nonsensical pollution as propagated by political campaigns, for parading political representatives in front of some leader who is at the helm of country’s affairs, but no one has enough funds to appreciate a genuine effort by young boys. And I am ashamed when the most so-perceived educated communicators, those blessed with a sharp bend of mind, thought and tongue, do not even have the courtesy to raise some intelligent noise about the same. Perhaps, they may write about these boys post-their struggle to reach newer heights and Celebrityhood, later in life.
Thanking Tathagata Bhattacharya of The Week! One’s social conscience needs to be awakened and its momentum to be sustained through capturing such precious journeys embarked upon by individuals – a child or an adult, to a large extent, go unnoticed by the materialistic world. Articles penned by individuals like you would nourish one’s forever-sagging social conscience, especially, in the forever-getting richer society where more and more families fumbling their way into “Nouveau Riche” segment, who pamper young blighters to a dismally disappointing extent that everything comes to them “gift-wrapped”, with zero-efforts, while a majority struggle on the streets for a handful of rice.

7 comments
Comments feed for this article
November 13, 2007 at 8:52 pm
Born a Libran
Make sure some of your journalist friends from the 24-hour news channels hear about this and sell the idea that this story could be big on said news channel. Within 24 hrs after they talk about it and the rest of the news channels hear about it, the mission will be accomplished. Sadly, that is what works in India…
November 14, 2007 at 4:43 am
jyothsnay
Born a Libran
thank you for ideating for me….you have moved too far away from your country, and learnt to talk like “Uncle Sam”….media in India is choosy n selective about their pieces, and they would consider pieces that have potential to launch them into the “Stratosphere Spray of Limelight”. I feel, such move is wholly unnecessary as it’s just a momentary spike on the screen which may not do justice these boys.
I wrote to three FMCG giants (think like an Advertising professional) who I believe would entertain avenues – Corporate responsibility, ..n rummaged them about the symbiotic existence of this nobel effort by these gentle young hearts and their brands-the values they stand for in the consumer minds. I am just the soldier who is running across the fields spreading the news…nothing much, but I will do what I can within my limits.
you appear to be a two-legged management stroll….have you ever read about Philip Knight “The Man behind the Swoosh”? and his strategy about “whispering loudly” and the “Athletics West Running club in Eugene”?
No…grab that book. at times, I feel, BRIC economies are a lot more intelligent than Developed Economics.you would fnd a much stronger survival instinct in economies where most struggle with poverty.the little lads are tough, they just need a nudge of appreciation
November 14, 2007 at 6:17 am
Born a Libran
Best of luck on ur endeavor – I hope you succeed as much for the little lads as for your belief in the system. While I will get my hands on the book you talk about, I think selling something to the media (and Indian media is getting very similar to the Western media in this sense) is about putting the right spin to the story (also call this strategy “Whispering loudly” if you want). Case in point is Prince’s struggle to get out of the gutter.
But enough argument already… You are actually going out and doing something about this and that is appreciated.
November 14, 2007 at 6:28 am
jyothsnay
I felt it but ignored it.someone chided me over it.I was rude to you, dnot ask me why so.I admit that I was rude in my language n tone , brush you aside. I sensed a sheer layer of arrogance in your voice,I could be wrong
Most transnationals n FMCGs in India have initiated CSR (Corporate Social Responsibility) and Category heads, personally, involved in each. It’s no longer a stand-alone PR stunt which would be given one-day high decible mileage.and interestingly, most these CSR are spun around the flagship brands – each brand stands for certain values and belief systems n talk to a specific target segment.Besides these, moderately large Technical force have become voluntary participants in such events too..read INTEL, HCL ..etc etc case studies, if you are interested in.
I wrote quite a bit on R’s posts on CSR…u need to dig the archives (again, the inclination)
It’s not just empty blogging n most tend to consider it as yet another CLAMMING activity…but to make it work is a difficult task, and the least one could do towards this is to create awareness, float the flag – my point of view…if not today, this moment, the WOM (word of mouth) campaign, the buzz works in a long run….the whole sense of having felt for someone who is in need is unparalleled.
I would certainly see a few workable updates on the same post soon….I am certain that there’s an audience for these youngsters. arguments are healthy, lopsided hopelessness, ideally, has to be ignored
November 14, 2007 at 6:34 am
jyothsnay
media …..perhaps, in your lands, it is responsive.in my land, the response comes sporadically like rains.I dismissed media response (excluding Tathagata Bhattacharya’s coverage) here outrightly cause the kind of inexplicable silence I got from them….
I wrote to TOI twice to get the details of the Orphanage, the correspondent covered. she mentioned that if one is interested do get in touch with xxxx@some mail.com……I wrote to her twice and I still wait for her response.sure, I do live in such hopeless society, but that does not mean that I need to lose grip on the frail thread of hope.
thank you writing in! I was abrasive…n apologies for that.you sounded too condescending, just like developed economies stare at the muddy slippers of developing economies…ironically, you hail from one of them
Reporters, in India, to a large extent, REPORT EVENTS.They dnot act upon them.A few have taken leaps to identify “high-yield” cases and lumber them upto the sizzln dizzying heights so that they could get the mileage, you know that TRPs, hits etc etc…Socially active, particpant journalism may have not seen the day light, but am happy that Public / Commners’ journalism is breathing a little morning breeze.
February 13, 2008 at 1:06 am
Shelley Seale
This is a wonderful story. As you mentioned, I featured this story on my blog – http://weightofsilence.wordpress.com – and also visited the CCD home in Calcutta last March. There I was able to meet Sahiful, Rinku, Ashikul and the other boys who have made these films. It was a truly wonderful experience. Thanks for giving them more coverage that they deserve.
Shelley Seale
March 11, 2008 at 5:36 am
jyothsnay
Dear Shelley Seale
Truly sorry for not having responded to your comment immediately/sooner. I have been amidst the throes n pangs of relocating my base to a city sea side
I find what you’d done, the time you spent time with those little brave-hearts, incredibly admirable…certain thoughtful acts n gestures of reaching out to others, especially little brilliant kids, which people like me plan but fail to act upon them….what you have done appeals to me some deep spiritual need of mine….
Take care….more POWER to you, dead lady
Jyo